On January 27, 2009,
a lawsuit was filed on behalf of Shanice Denise Osbourne.
In July 2006, Shanice's mother, 18-year-old Sycloria Williams, who was 23 weeks pregnant, went to a Miami abortion clinic for an abortion that was to be performed by Dr. Pierre Jean-Jacque Renelique. At the clinic, Williams was given Cytotec by the clinic's receptionist to induce labor. However, Renelique was late, and while Williams was waiting for him to arrive, she delivered a live baby girl.
What happened next is, supposedly, shocking.
One of the clinic owners, Belkis Gonzalez, cut the umbilical cord, placed the baby in a plastic biohazard bag, and threw the bag into a trash can. Police later found the baby's remains decomposing in a cardboard box.
Now, everyone is expressing shock and outrage that this would happen.
Tom Brejcha, president of The Thomas More Society, a law firm representing Williams, said, "The baby was just treated as a piece of garbage. People all over the country are just aghast."
Even Joanne Sterner, president of the Broward County chapter of the pro-abortion National Organization for Women expressed disapproval. "It really disturbed me. I know that there are clinics out there like this. And I hope that we can keep (women) from going to these types of clinics."
Why are these people upset by this? I don't see a problem. Sycloria Williams went to this clinic with the intention of having an abortion. If Dr. Renelique had been there on time, she would have had the abortion. Her baby would have been dead. That was her intention.
So Dr. Renelique was late, and the baby was born. Belkis Gonzalez, who didn't have the medical expertise to kill the baby while she was still in her mother's womb, simply killed her after she had been delivered. So what? The baby is now dead, and that's why Miss Williams went to the clinic in the first place. That's why she was waiting for Dr. Renelique. She was waiting for him to come in and kill her baby. When you think about it, this way is probably better. Abortions can be hard on the mother. There can be complications. Once the baby is delivered, however, he or she can be easily killed with almost no risk to the mother.
Miami attorney Tom Pennekamp, also representing Williams, said, "She (Williams) came face to face with a human being, and that changed everything." What? Why did that change anything? Of course this little girl was a human being, but she was also a human being thirty minutes earlier when her mother was waiting for Dr. Renelique to come in and perform the abortion. Just because her mother hadn't come "face to face" with her yet didn't mean she wasn't a human being. Nobody had a problem with killing this baby girl minutes before she emerged from her mother's womb, so what was the problem with killing her minutes after she emerged from her mother's womb? The only difference was her location. One minute she was within her mother's womb; next minute she was outside her mother's womb. So what? She didn't suddenly become something that she wasn't before. Her location changed; that's all. No big deal.
So why is Williams suing Gonzalez, Renelique, and the clinic? She got what she wanted: a dead baby. Okay, maybe should be a little upset with Renelique for being late, but she ought to thank Gonzalez. Williams wanted her baby dead, and Gonzalez made that happen for her. If it hadn't been for Gonzales and the baby had lived, Williams would had to have made the difficult choice of either raising her baby or putting it up for adoption. Now, thanks to Gonzalez, she doesn't have to worry about it. Her baby is dead, and she is relieved of all personal responsibility for the child.
Sycloria Williams ought to be happy with the way things turned out.